When the mains fails, the toilet is the first thing people discover they cannot improvise. A flush needs 6 to 9 litres of water each time, and a household producing waste with nowhere to put it becomes a disease problem within days.
A twin-bucket composting toilet solves it with no water, no plumbing and no power, and it can run indoors indefinitely without smelling.
Why this rather than a latrine
| Bucket system | Dug latrine | |
|---|---|---|
| Water needed | None | None |
| Indoors? | Yes | No |
| Winter | Fine | Miserable and often frozen |
| Effort | Emptying a bucket | Digging |
| Ground needed | None | Suitable ground, well away from water |
| Output | Compost, after a year | Buried, wasted |
| Best for | A household staying put | Short stays, camps, no container |
For a household bugging in, the bucket wins on almost every count, and the decisive one in a British winter is that it works indoors. A latrine at the bottom of the garden in February, in the dark, in the rain, gets used less than it should, and that is how people end up doing something worse.
The system
Urine and faeces go in the same bucket. Separating them is a common refinement and it is not necessary; the mixed material composts well and the cover material handles the moisture. Keeping it simple matters more than optimising it.
Cover material is the whole trick
Good cover material, best first:
- Sawdust, untreated, from a sawmill or joinery. The standard, and often free. Not from treated timber.
- Wood shavings, though coarser and less absorbent than sawdust.
- Peat-free compost or coir.
- Dry shredded leaves, collected in autumn and kept dry.
- Shredded paper and cardboard, which work and are less absorbent.
- Dry grass clippings, straw, chopped bracken.
- Wood ash, sparingly, mixed with something else. Alone it is too alkaline and slows composting.
Using it
- Put a few centimetres of cover material in the bottom of a fresh bucket.
- Use it normally. Paper goes in too.
- Cover completely after every use, including urine. A scoop or two.
- Keep the lid on when not in use.
- Swap the bucket when it is about three-quarters full. Not to the brim, because it has to be carried.
- Carry it out and empty it onto the heap.
- Rinse the empty bucket with a little water, tip the rinse water onto the heap, and add fresh cover material.
Empty every few days rather than letting it fill completely. A part-full bucket is far easier and safer to carry, and the smell only becomes an issue when the material is disturbed.
Wash hands afterwards, every time, without exception. This is the single most important hygiene behaviour in the entire sanitation domain, and it is the one that lapses when water is short. Keep a dedicated handwashing point next to the toilet and next to the heap.
The compost heap
Method:
- Start with a thick base of coarse material: straw, hay, brash, wood chip, half a metre of it. This absorbs liquid and lets air in from below.
- Always deposit into a hollow in the centre of the heap, then cover immediately and completely with straw, hay or leaves.
- Never leave anything exposed.
- Add kitchen scraps, garden waste and cover material to the same heap. A mixed heap composts far better than a single-input one.
- Do not turn it if you are following the classic method. Building it undisturbed and letting it cure is the point.
- When it is full, cap it thickly with straw and start a second heap.
A well-built heap heats to 50 to 65°C in its core within days, and that thermophilic phase does most of the pathogen destruction: 55°C sustained for 72 hours is generally sufficient for common pathogens, and 62°C kills them within about an hour.
A heap that does not heat still works, just more slowly, relying on time rather than temperature. That is precisely why the curing year exists.
The year, which is not negotiable
When it smells
A correctly run system smells of sawdust and nothing else. A smell means something specific.
| Smell | Cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Ammonia in the bucket | Not enough cover material | More cover, every use |
| Faecal smell in the bucket | Material exposed | Cover completely |
| Smell from the heap | Deposits not covered on the heap | Always cover with straw immediately |
| Sour, sewage smell from the heap | Too wet, gone anaerobic | Add coarse dry carbon, improve the base |
| Flies | Something exposed somewhere | Find it and cover it |
Flies are the signal to act on immediately, not the smell. Flies mean an exposed surface, an exposed surface means faecal-oral transmission, and that is the thing this whole system exists to prevent.
In a household with children, keep the toilet area and the heap firmly out of bounds, and make handwashing a rule that is enforced rather than encouraged. The children's tier says the same thing from the other side.